Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Book Annotation-Women’s Lives and Relationships



Author: Elizabeth Berg

Title: Home Safe

Genre: Women’s Lives and Relationships

Publication Date: 2009

Number of Pages: 260

Geographical Setting: Chicago, IL

Time Period: The Oughties

Series: NA

Appeal Terms: Character-driven, Amusing, Bittersweet, Heartwarming

Plot Summary:
It’s been nearly a year since Helen Ames lost her husband, Dan, the love of her life, her financial planner, handyman, and provider who’s steady income allowed Helen to pursue and achieve the best-selling author status that she now enjoys.  Dan’s industry has left Helen little financial worries, though she’s afraid she may never be able to write again, until a tense call from her accountant informs her that the nearly million dollars the Ames’ had stowed away together had suffered an $850,000 withdrawal by Dan several months before his death.  Helen’s thoughts immediately imagine another woman, a second family, or a gambling problem, but she is comforted by her adult daughter, Tessa’s, unshaking faith in her father as a man of unimpeachable integrity.  Eventually the money will surface, Helen feels fairly sure, but she is unable to imagine the form or challenges it will bring with it.  Helen also knows she is going to have to learn to stand on her own more now and allow her friends, neighbors, and Tessa the opportunity of pursuing their own paths through life.
Berg’s book makes the strong appeal to readers’ emotions early on with the death of Helen’s husband Dan that identifies this novel strongly with the genre or Women’s Lives and Relationships (Saricks, 2009).  The novel also exhibits another strong element of its genre in the network of relationships that support Helen with scenes involving three generations of women in her family (her mother, Eleanor, and daughter, Tessa), conversations with her best-friend, Midge, and professional relationships (and rivalries) with other female authors (Saricks, 2009).  The tone is thoughtful and full of images of home and reconciliation with, as Saricks points out, a “hopeful” ending (2009).  One of the last elements that indicates Berg’s novel’s genre is the leisurely pace, a hallmark of books of Women’s Lives and Relationships (Saricks, 2009).

Fiction Read-Alikes:

PS, I Love You by Cecelia Ahern
Sharing the appeal factors of Amusing, Bittersweet, and Heartwarming with Berg’s novel, this book concerning Women’s Lives and Relationships deals in similar plot details of the loss of a spouse and learning what to do with that spouse’s legacy.  In Berg’s book the spousal legacy takes a very inadvertent, though concrete form while in Ahern’s book the spousal legacy seems to be more deliberate and goal-oriented.  Both of these novels are leisurely-paced and character-driven, and though the protagonists are quite different in age, Berg’s Helen is 59 and Ahern’s Holly is 29, there is plenty of emotional connection for readers of any age.

The First Time by Joy Fielding
Sharing the subject of Mothers and Daughters and the location, Chicago, IL, this novel of Women’s Lives and Relationships focuses, rather than on the life change event of a spouse’s sudden passing, on the break in a marriage after a husband’s infidelity and a wife, Mattie’s, diagnosis with ALS.  A theme of reconciliation runs deeply through Fielding’s novel, not only relationally between husband and wife and daughter, but also, like Berg’s novel, in a larger perspective of characters coming to grips with the new shape of their lives.

Milk Glass Moon by Adriana Trigiani, Big Stone Gap Book 3
Berg’s novel was so “gentle” that this Gentle Read by Trigiani dealing with a mother watching her daughter move into being an adult and weathering the possible mid-life crisis of her husband could be a shoo-in for readers.  Character-Driven and Heartwarming are appeal factors shared by the two books along with the domestic network of female characters common to the genre Women’s Lives and Relationships.

Nonfiction Read-Alike:

Saturday Night Widows: The Adventures of Six Friends Remaking Their Lives by Becky Aikman
In this story of a group of widows reimagining and playing out what widowhood can be for women is captured the conciliatory and character-driven nature of Berg’s novel.  Sharing the appeal factor of Bittersweet with Berg’s novel, Aikman, also a writer, follows her own journey along with the five other widows in her Saturday night club through the cycle of grief.

Work Cited:
Saricks, J. (2009). The Readers' Advisory Guide to Genre Fiction. Chicago, IL: American Library Association.

9 comments:

  1. Craig,
    I don't typically read in this genre, but, your description hinted at a mystery buried in the plot as well as relationship issues. I enjoy stories that have a mystery to solve along the way. So, I looked at a Kirkus review to learn more and was surprised to read a less than favorable description of the plot, "Berg seems to fall back on her default worldview: Her characters are simply too nice, too timid or both, to get themselves into any interesting messes," (https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/elizabeth-berg/home-safe/). Further reading of the review told me that missing money was found...as a gift from Helen's husband to surprise her with a California dream house. I have to say, I was a little disappointed and had hopes for some grand money mystery there. Saricks says that novels in this genre center around relationships, especially the "healing and discovering solutions to problems that many women share," (Saricks 159). That certainly seems accurate with Safe Home and Helen's loss of husband, find of romance and roller-coaster professional world...I was just hoping for a bit more depth to the missing money mystery...your thoughts?
    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh yeah, there's not really too much mystery. It seems at first that there could be, but Berg doesn't take too long to do the reveal. I guess for me that fits with the genre, but even for this genre the book does seem to lack some dynamism.

      Delete
  2. Hi Craig! Nice job on your annotation and great job going out of your comfort zone to read a women's lives & relationship book! And, you gave excellent reasons for why you choose the read-a-likes you selected.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Craig,

    From reading through your annotation, I can see that this is one of those books which lets people experience the moments as the characters do. As someone who doesn't generally read in this genre, I don't have a great deal of familiarity with particular titles or authors, but I could understand why certain people find this a very relaxing and welcoming kind of book to read. Just as with certain mystery authors (where you know the detective will solve the case and no one of importance will be killed along the way), this feels like a good genre for those who want a sense of peace as they are reading. They know, in the end, that it will all be alright. Will the ending necessarily be 'believable'? Perhaps not from our perspective as people who live in a not-always-happy world, but then...I read fantasies and romances. Soooooo...HEAs and genies granting wishes are pretty much par for the course with me :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is quite a relaxing read. As I mentioned in my read-alike suggestions, for me it borders on a Gentle Read. Not usually my cup of tea, but an good and informative experience overall.

      Delete
  4. Hi, Craig. I'm glad you mentioned the bit about this book "border(ing) on a Gentle Read". I guess I am still struggling with the difference between the two. (I'd better go back and re-read the chapters, I reckon!)

    Nice job "hinting" at the mystery in the book while not blowing it for your readers either in your annotation or in your comment. I really appreciate that there are no spoilers!

    By the way, I wondered if everyone noticed the very timely article in Booklist? It's by Michael Ruzicka, dated 3-1-18, and the title is "Middle Grade reading and Women's Fiction". (I tried to bold "Women's Fiction" but couldn't get it to work.) I think it's especially interesting in that Joyce Saricks is featured in the article AND she writes in our text, "Although some call this genre Women's Fiction, I find that term too limiting, as it could suggest to the uninitiated that this is all that women read. Or that this is what women should read. Or what we should suggest to any woman who asks for assistance" (p. 155). Clearly "Women's Fiction" is not a moniker of which she's particularly fond. She had to be gritting her teeth when she saw that headline! Here's the article if anyone is interested: http://www.booklistreader.com/2018/03/01/books-and-authors/the-latest-booklist-spotlight-on-middle-grade-reading-womens-fiction/

    ReplyDelete
  5. This sounds super interesting! I did my annotation on this genre, but Women's Lives & Relationships is actually a genre I don't read much, so I was prepared to not be intrigued by the titles floating around this week. However, this one has my attention, and I'm especially sold by the fact that it's an uber gentle read--mine was NOT, and I was incredibly disappointed.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This book sounds really interesting. I don't read many books like this, but I have read the first book in Adriana Trigiani's Big Stone Gap series. I might have to pick this one up sometime.

    ReplyDelete